Will be keeping the list short and sweet this year, as I just want to highlight the few things that truly made an impact. It’s an inexhaustive list, with certain shows originally meriting inclusion (“Cobra Kai” season 4 was its normal good show, and then season 5 went off the rails) only to fall off the list. As in years past, the list is chronological to when I saw it/when the show or movie originally was released. Feel free to disagree with my choices in the comments!
Peacemaker (HBO Max): This show had no business being anywhere near as entertaining as it ended up being. This is John Cena’s star turn, a show fused with DC comics history and James Gunn’s insane experimentation.
Somebody Somewhere (HBO): Bridget Everrett plays a loose version of herself in Nebraska. Short on plot but long on character, I really enjoyed this one.
The Afterparty (Apple TV+): As it stands, my favorite show of the year. I love a whodunnit, I love love love this cast (Ben Schwartz, Ilana Glazer, Ike Barinholtz, Sam Richardson, Tiffany Hadish, etc., etc.) and each episode spoofed a different movie genre. I’ve had “Yeah Sure Whatever” in my head since early February.
Pam & Tommy (Hulu): Please give Lily James every award imaginable for transforming into Pamela Anderson, and give any leftover awards to the hair and makeup team. What a fun ride this show turned out to be.
The Dropout (Hulu): Speaking of amazing, transformative performances, Amanda Seyfried killed it as Elizabeth Holmes on this show.
“Now I’m Up,” SNL (NBC): Another song that’s been stuck in my head most of the year.
Life & Beth (Hulu): Yet another well-done Hulu limited series. This might be the best we’ve seen Michael Cera in years, here playing a thinly-veiled version of Amy Schumer’s real-life husband. Fun twists and turns, really great casting, and while not as funny as you might expect from a Schumer project, overall really great.
The Oscars Slap (ABC): I do not remember anything from before or after this moment during the show. I only recall furiously scrolling on Twitter (remember the good days on Twitter before Elon?) to try to figure out what just happened.
Moon Knight (Disney+): You had me at Oscar Isaac in a Marvel show. Certainly the only Marvel show or show on Disney+ in general to deal with both superpowers and dissociative identity disorder. (Note: She-Hulk, Ms. Marvel, and the Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special just missed my list.)
I Love that for You (Showtime): A sneaky-good show, with a solid premise that was well executed. Very much hoping for a second season.
Obi-Wan Kenobi (Disney+): If you had told me in 2005 that we’d be getting a rematch of Vader vs. Obi-Wan, I would have been giddy. While some of the show dragged, that epic fight at the end of episode 6 more than made up for it.
Severance (Apple TV+): Probably the most polarizing show in my household in quite some time, this show was exactly the kind of mind-bending sci-fi I love, with outstanding performances all around, especially from lead Adam Scott.
Winning Time (HBO): The kind of show that asks, “what if we just did EVERYTHING?” Shot in different formats, using every fourth-wall breaking cliche imaginable, this show was a must-watch in the spring.
Russian Doll Season 2 (Netflix): The rare show whose second season shows why it was merited. This show is bonkers in all the right ways, and Natasha Lyonne gave a star-making turn.
Barry Season 3 (HBO): Also a show that could have neatly ended after its first season, Barry continues to really challenge what a “comedy” is supposed to look like. Bonus points for having the absolute best scene of television this year:
Hacks, Season 2 (HBO Max): Not quite as sharp as the original season, this show is still laugh out loud funny, thanks mostly to the amazing performance of Jean Smart.
Chip ‘n Dale Rescue Rangers (Disney+): This movie had no business being nearly as funny as it was. As someone who grew up on the “Disney afternoon” (Chip ‘n Dale, Tail Spin, Goof Troop, etc.), I was thrilled to see my favorites back on my TV.
I Want You Back (Amazon Prime): Every so often, you’ll read a story about how the rom-com is dead. It’s not. There just are not that many good ones anymore. I Want You Back, with Charlie Day and Jenny Slate, was one of the good ones.
Good Luck to you, Leo Grande (Amazon Prime): Knockout performance by Emma Thompson. This is one of those movies that feels like a play (in the best way possible).
Only Murders in the Building Season 2 (Hulu): The chemistry between Steve Martin and Martin Short remains palpable, and the twist ending of this season (and fun cameo of season 3’s victim) topped the ending of the first season.
The Bear (FX on Hulu): Show of the summer. Probably the best or second-best TV show of the year. Jeremy Allen White’s star-making turn? “Yes, chef!”
Trainwreck: Woodstock ’99 (Netflix): What a house of horrors that festival turned out to be. Great, gripping documentary.
Abbott Elementary (ABC): A network sitcom? In this era? Abbott is such a throwback to the good old days of classic network sitcoms, but also uses de rigeur The Office-style talking heads. Great, great show.
Top Gun: Maverick: Maybe the movie of the year? Honestly, no other film exceeded my expectations as much as this one. “Talk to me, Goose.”
Andor (Disney+): At least they saved the best Star Wars content for the end of the year. After the trainwreck of Book of Boba Fett, Andor came along and saved the day.
Jeopardy: Tournament of Champions (ABC): Amy Schneider was a dominant champion, but watching her battle Andrew He and Sam Buttrey in the finals was the stuff of legend.
Welcome to Chippendales (Hulu): Another fun based-on-a-true-story Hulu miniseries, with great performances from Kumail Nanjiani, Analeigh Ashford, and Juliette Lewis.
Fleishman is in Trouble (Hulu): Sometimes shows are made with great scripts, or great directing, or great music. Fleishman has all of that, yes, but this show is an example of just capital-t Terrific casting. Jesse Eisenberg, Lizzy Caplan, Adam Brody, Josh Radnor, Claire Danes, and on and on, this is the most lived-in, fully aware show in quite some time.
Best TV shows: The Afterparty, The Bear, Severance, Fleishman is in Trouble, Abbott Elementary, Barry, Winning Time
Best movie: Top Gun: Maverick
Best streamer: Hulu, by a mile! Only Murders, The Dropout, Pam & Tommy, Life and Beth, Fleishman is in Trouble, The Bear, and reruns of Abbott.
Other things that nearly made my list: Underwhelming second seasons of The Flight Attendant and Made for Love (the latter of which was cancelled); The Batman; The Resort; The White Lotus, Season 2; The Banshees of Inisherin; Dr. Strange and the Multiverse of Madness and Black Panther: Wakanda Forever (both good, but worse than their original films); Under the Banner of Heaven (great performance by Andrew Garfield but the show was a bit muddled); Big Mouth season 6; Better Call Saul (only because we are only on season 5, and it would not be fair to rank it without having actually seen it); This is Us (the finale really did not stick the landing); We Own This City; Ghislaine Maxwell: Filthy Rich (not as interesting a doc as I’d come to expect); The Patient (although Steve Carell was terrific); Pepsi, Where’s my Jet (first episode was strong but grew less interesting as the show went on)
Disappointments: Bros (even though I really like Billy Eichner); The Book of Boba Fett (except for the Mandalorian/Luke Skywalker/Grogu episodes); Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore; Ms. Marvel; Killing It; Don’t Worry, Darling (never a great sign when the press tour is miles ahead of the movie you’re promoting).
So long, farewell to the Netflix shows my wife watched: Dead to Me, Grace and Frankie, and Ozark, you will be missed by some.
I have yet to see: The Whale, The Fabelmans, She Said.
In Memoriam: An extremely talented group of performers left us this year, including but not limited to Betty White, John Madden, Sidney Poitier, Peter Bogdonavich, Bob Saget, Meat Loaf, Louie Anderson, Ivan Reitman, Gilbert Gottfried, Estelle Harris, Fred Ward, Ray Liotta, James Caan, Denise Dowse, Paul Sorvino, Anne Heche, Vin Scully, Joe E. Tata, and Angela Lansbury. Rest in peace.